Wednesday, 21 December 2011

Good paper... must... reject...

A colleague and I recently received the review outcome for one of our conference papers. This is an excerpt of the feedback from one of the reviewers:
*** Reasons to accept: Please give the main reasons for accepting the paper.
(this was actually blank)

*** Reasons to reject: Please give the main reasons for rejecting the paper.
This article is very well written. The contribution is interesting and the results are encouraging.
The final outcome was "accept" :D